You are currently viewing 5 Key Takeaways from the Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl Review – Unearthing Rusted Platinum
Pokemon Brilliant Diamond

5 Key Takeaways from the Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl Review – Unearthing Rusted Platinum

Introduction to Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl

The release of Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl has sparked excitement among fans, offering a nostalgic trip back to the beloved Gen 4 region. However, while these remakes have their charms, they fall short of delivering the best version of Gen 4, especially when compared to the exceptional Pokemon Platinum. Let’s delve into the reasons behind this sentiment and explore the various aspects of the game.

A Familiar Journey

As we embark on our adventure in Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl, we find ourselves exploring the captivating Sinnoh region. The game presents us with familiar characters and creative Pokemon designs, maintaining the essence of the original Diamond & Pearl versions. Sinnoh’s beauty and intriguing characters make it hard to envision a version that could be anything less than remarkable.

The Missing Spark from Platinum

Unfortunately, despite its positive attributes, Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl falls short of capturing the magic of Pokemon Platinum, which improved upon the original Gen 4 games in numerous ways. Platinum gave prominence to Sinnoh’s best characters like Dawn, Cynthia, and Cyrus, offering a more enriched storytelling experience. The region itself felt more immersive, resembling a living world rather than a mere video game setting. In contrast, Shining Pearl’s art direction and design choices raise questions and hinder the game’s overall experience.

The Art Direction Dilemma

Shining Pearl’s art style presents a mixed bag of impressions. While some may find the chibi aesthetics cute, it clashes with the serious tone of Sinnoh’s story. Characters that were once austere now appear lighthearted, which can disconnect players from the narrative. Moreover, the vibrant colors don’t always complement Sinnoh’s harsh landscapes, diluting the original atmosphere.

Gameplay and Design Quirks

Several gameplay and design choices further highlight the gap between Shining Pearl and its predecessor, Platinum. The battles, while slightly improved, still feel slow and extended, especially in wild encounters. Shining Pearl also makes the mistake of reintroducing certain issues from the original games, like persnickety controls and lack of catchable Fire-types, except Ponyta.

The Odd Addition of Hideaways

Shining Pearl introduces new Hideaways in the Grand Underground, which promise exciting Pokemon encounters. However, the implementation falls short of expectations, resembling Mystery Dungeon levels more than the anticipated miniature Wild Areas. The increased catch rates also feel inconsistent, resulting in perplexing moments like Beldum Struggling to death despite multiple attempts to catch it.

Despite the Flaws, a Captivating Journey

Despite the criticism, Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl still offer an enjoyable journey through the beloved Gen 4 region. The game boasts stylish and thoughtful Pokemon designs, an engaging story, and improvements to certain aspects like hidden moves and UI navigation. However, considering the superiority of Pokemon Platinum in almost every way, the necessity of these remakes raises questions.


In conclusion, Pokemon Brilliant Diamond & Shining Pearl are commendable remakes of the original Diamond & Pearl, offering a nostalgic trip to Sinnoh with its alluring characters and Pokemon designs. However, when compared to the exceptional enhancements found in Pokemon Platinum, these remakes fall short of delivering the best possible Gen 4 experience. While they shine brightly, they can’t quite match the brilliance of their predecessor from 13 years ago.

Leave a Reply